‘Rogue One’ Has a Women Problem

In a universe where star wars are possible, there just aren't many women around.

rogue-one-gallery24_034ab5e8

StarWars.com | Rogue One

Warning: This article contains spoilers for Rogue One: A Star Wars Story. If you haven’t seen it yet, encase yourself in frozen carbonite and come back when you’ve recovered from hibernation sickness.

In a 1978 interview on The Tonight Show, Johnny Carson asked astronomer Carl Sagan about the scientific accuracy of the Star Wars films. Sagan responded with disappointment about the one-dimensionality of the series’ creatures: “They’re all white. The skin of all the humans in Star Wars, oddly enough, is sort of like this [points to his skin] and not even the other colours represented on the earth are present, much less greens and blues and purples and oranges. […] Everybody in charge of the galaxy seems to look like us.”

It appears our culture still has a narrow imagination. Like most other pop culture objects, studio executives prefer our onscreen heroes to be white, male, able-bodied, thin, and straight. Even in science fiction, where alternate realities, alien societies, and strange worlds are possible (in galaxies far, far, away, no less), our films and television series’ end up mimicking patriarchal structures that exist in the “real” world. Rogue One, A Star Wars Story is no exception.

Rogue One has a women problem. In short, there aren’t many. In a universe where space wars are possible on a massive scale, where droids are self-aware, and where weapons made of light can cut through anything, there just don’t seem to be many women around. You’d think, in a galaxy-wide rebellion, there’d be at least a handful of women who cared enough to fight. They can’t all be stuck at home scavenging ship parts for Insta-bread portions and schlepping “Little Ani”s around.

Skeptics will point to the fact that our main character, Jyn Erso (Felicity Jones), is a woman, marking the second film in Disney’s Star Wars reboot that features a female lead. But this does not change the irrefutable fact that Jyn’s entire entourage – Cassian Andor, Chirrut Imwe, Bodhi Rook, Baze Malbus, even the droid K-2SO (Alan Tudyk) – is made up of men. Were there really no female martial artists for hire? Or the one they cast couldn’t quite handle the “I am one with the Force. The Force is with me” mantra?

rogue-one-gallery11_9d51c99f

StarWars.com | Rogue One

The lack of female characters in the Rogue One squadron is compounded by the painful fact that, as a viewer, it is hard to relate to or care about Jyn. Like with other squad members, Rogue One takes almost no time to develop its characters. We never get to know what makes Cassian tick (other than, well, the Empire?), why Bodhi defected from the Imperial army, nor what caused the Alliance to view Saw Gerrera’s tactics as “too extreme.” Most importantly, as she’s our main character, we don’t feel the personal stakes behind Jyn’s reluctant mission to steal the Death Star’s data tapes. Unfortunately, this leaves our much lauded female hero feeling flat and uninteresting. Making Jyn Erso the centre of Rogue One, it seems, is nothing more than a token gesture in an overwhelming man’s (star) world.

On occasion, we did catch glimpses of other women in the galaxy: Mon Mothma, Jyn’s mother, the unnamed black Senator at the Alliance table, the unnamed female fighter pilot, and even a (stiff) digital likeness of the late Carrie Fisher as Princess Leia. However, there is no denying the rest of Rogue One is predominantly male. There’s a scene where Cassian Andor approaches Jyn with a small army of Rogue fighters ready for a rebellion. As I watched, I couldn’t help but feel angry that the film presumes women wouldn’t make up a major facet of the rebellion and frustration at the missed opportunity to be more inclusive. After 40 years, how can a franchise have regressed in its representation of women?

There is no doubt that Rogue One succeeds at progressivism in its diverse (male) casting choices – there are a wide array of skin colours, accents, and physical abilities in this film. However, you cannot achieve progress unless it is progress for everyone. In this sense, Rogue One is a regrettable step backwards for the representation of women in popular science fiction. As I left the theatre, it was difficult to feel anything resembling Princess Leia’s final word: “hope.”

rogue-one-gallery44_1c3a644b

StarWars.com | Rogue One

About Malory Beazley (34 Articles)
Malory has taken her interest in fandom to the academy, penning a Master's thesis entitled "Out of the Cupboards and Into the Streets!: Harry Potter Genderfuck Fan Fiction and Fan Activism." You can find her in Nova Scotia, sipping coffee, writing fiction, and reading slash.

4 Comments on ‘Rogue One’ Has a Women Problem

  1. Well written review! I took similar issue with the film. My husband and I saw it the other day, and that evening I remarked to him, “Don’t you find it odd that literally every Imperial character shown was white, male, middle-aged, clean-shaven, and able-bodied? And the Resistance characters weren’t that much more diverse?” I agree with you that all of the characters felt quite flat. I had a very difficult time understanding what anyone’s motivation really was. Quite disappointing!

    • FAN/FIC Magazine // December 30, 2016 at 4:25 pm // Reply

      Completely agree! And a similar thing happened with “The Force Awakens.” They had this great trifecta of somewhat diverse characters (Rey, Finn, Poe), but by Act II the trio had largely been upstaged by the “nostalgic” cameos by Harrison Ford, Carrie Fisher, the droids, etc. I wish Disney would have just trusted their new cast of characters to win over audiences. Because Rey-Finn-Poe (and BB8!) are great. I was hoping “Rogue One” would lean in this more progressive direction, but, alas, it created an even bigger problem with its outrageous erasure of women. Disappointing is right!

      Thank you for the kind words and for reading/commenting. 🙂

      • I wish Poe had been there the whole time, with Han having a smaller supporting role. Then they could be a real trio. I enjoyed reading your article. Thanks. 🙂

        • FAN/FIC Magazine // January 6, 2017 at 5:01 pm // Reply

          Yes, I would have loved to see more of Poe Dameron (Oscar Isaac is fantastic), especially within the new trio. That way Finn would have been the glue holding them together (Finn/Rey friendship vs. Finn/Poe friendship). Alas, as with most other recent Hollywood blockbusters, nostalgia for past characters and actors won out. Thanks so much for reading and commenting! Glad you enjoyed it. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: